Yes, seriously.
I get the train into Charing Cross from Brockley every day. I tend to use an Oyster Card because, well, it’s convenient. Except when it goes wrong and you have to deal with a bunch of people in India to try and get a refund.
This morning the ticket barriers at Brockley were broken. No way to swipe in with my oyster card. In fact the barriers were in pieces and there was no way to use any kind of ticket! I checked with the staff (evidently a lot of people were confused) and was told to go through anyway and that I’d be charged at Charing Cross.
So with some deep misgivings off I went. 09:17 Southern train to London Bridge then the SouthEastern service to Charing Cross.
When I arrived at Charing Cross the gate staff said they’d seen a few people from Brockley with this problem and – clearly disinterested – told me I’d have to pay the full fare for a single ticket. That’s 40p more than the fare I’d have paid with Oyster. I questioned this, pointing out that I’d tried to pay the correct Oyster fare and that no additional cost had been mentioned they refused to negotiate and repeatedly told me it was “just the regulations”, “I’d have to complain to Tfl for a refund in writing” and there was nothing they could do. When I asked in return for the staff to give me a written explanation of why they were imposing the excess charge, they refused.
They further explained that the inflated fare was covered by the Oyster terms and conditions – but didn’t offer a copy or say whether those terms applied, given I had not been informed of the additional fare or been given the opportunity to decline it. Can you be bound by a contract when no money has changed hands and nobody’s told you the price isn’t as originally advertised?
I suggested I use my Oyster card to pay the correct fare at that end of the journey but was told “the system isn’t setup for it”. Then I suggested I simply pay the correct Oyster fare in cash and was told that – despite having remained polite and calm throughout – that I would be arrested if I tried to leave the station without paying for a full single ticket.
W. T. F.
Eventually I and another passenger with the same problem called the police over and they apologetically explained they really would have to arrest us if we wouldn’t pay the additional fare.
And that was that. Basically imprisoned at Charing Cross or forced to pay a higher, unannounced fare. I’d played nice, remained polite throughout and tried to follow the rules. So much for that.
Whoever employs the staff at Charing Cross – let’s talk about this. Overcharging passengers at the far end of the journey when it’s your own equipment at fault and threatening them with arrest if they don’t submit to the mafia-style shakedown is truly beyond the pale. Furthermore, telling passengers at Brockley they could pay at the other end but neglecting to mention the price would be higher – isn’t that simply fraud?
I know it’s only 40p but seriously, Tfl, SouthEastern, what the HELL are you playing at? What kind of a service threatens its customers with a criminal record when all they try to do is pay the advertised price for something?
![]()
NB: SouthEastern/Tfl/whoever – so as to avoid the popular “privacy forbids us from discussing individual cases” excuse – you have my full permission to publicly discuss what happened this morning. Please, I really want to hear your version.

